• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to 3 Brothers Pizza Cafe

3 Brothers Pizza Cafe is a vegan and Italian restaurant located in Farmingdale, NY. With a wide range of options such as buffalo chicken pizza, traditional Bianca pie, and chicken bacon ranch pizza, they cater to diverse tastes. Their feed your family combo is a great deal, offering a variety of dishes including pizza, hero, pasta, and salad. The ambiance is casual and family-friendly, perfect for lunch or dinner. The restaurant also offers catering services and has amenities like outdoor seating and Wi-Fi. Overall, 3 Brothers Pizza Cafe provides delicious food in a welcoming atmosphere that appeals to a wide audience.

3 Brothers Pizza Cafe: Reviews & Ratings

Jim F.
Jim F.

We showed up on a Sunday mid-afternoon with very short notice, party of 14. Fresh from a burial and graveside service. They accommodated us beautifully. The food was fine but the hospitality takes the cake.

Simone S.
Simone S.

Vegan food is amazing. Gentlemen making the pizza is great. Great customer service Just expensive.

Sean B.
Sean B.

This is the spot for good pizza unlike the crap in the surrounding area that want to pass off as good pizza. I always get a small traditional pie with pepperoni and sometimes without. It brings me back to the older days. Stick to traditional and you won't have a problem. I like this place and will go back over and over again.

Breana D.
Breana D.

We came here on Friday 11/1/24 Saidi and Carlos are wonderful! Carlos is so happy and friendly, we really appreciated the warm welcome and great food. There's an entire vegan menu!!!!! We will definitely be back!

Vassilikie O.
Vassilikie O.

Excellent food and service. Friendly staff. The Vegan options are endless! The pizza great! The eggplant rollotini! The mac and cheeze ball the best!

Lisa T.
Lisa T.

We came here yesterday for some vegan eats, and it was such a pleasant experience! Our waitress was really helpful! She surprised us with two of the best desserts on the menu! The death by chocolate cake was out of this world! Every bite was rich and chocolatey, and tasted even better paired with a tall glass of cold soy milk! I was impressed by the extent of the vegan menu. Classic Italian dishes gone vegan- without missing the mark. You can't go wrong with the vegan mozzarella sticks or the oyster mushroom calamari. For entrees we had the eggplant rollatini and stuffed shells, both excellent! It was my first time trying cashew ricotta, and I was thoroughly impressed. Oh I have also heard that they serve the best grandma slice around!!!

Location

3 Brothers Pizza Cafe is a hidden gem located in Farmingdale, NY, offering a delicious variety of vegan, pizza, and Italian dishes. This cozy cafe not only takes reservations but also offers delivery and takeout options for those who prefer dining at home. The restaurant is wheelchair accessible, accepts credit cards, and provides a casual dining atmosphere with a moderate noise level.

When it comes to the menu, 3 Brothers Pizza Cafe does not disappoint. Their regular specialty pizzas such as the Buffalo Chicken Pizza and Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza are a must-try for pizza lovers. They also offer build-your-own large pizzas, entrees like Traditional Eggplant Rollatini and Chicken Marsala, and a Feed Your Family Combo that includes a variety of dishes worth $50 for only $39.95.

What sets 3 Brothers Pizza Cafe apart is their attention to detail and quality ingredients. The Traditional Bianca Pie, with its classic New York flavors, is a favorite among customers. The Seafood Combination dish with clams, shrimp, mussels, and calamari in garlic white wine sauce or marinara sauce is a seafood lover's dream.

Overall, 3 Brothers Pizza Cafe is a great spot for a casual meal with friends and family. The restaurant offers catering services, has gender-neutral restrooms, outdoor seating, and even allows dogs on the premises. Whether you're looking for a quick lunch or a relaxed dinner, 3 Brothers Pizza Cafe has something for everyone.